Our resident editors and movie experts, James and Tim, are finally here to give you their authoritative lists of the objectively best movies of all time, like The Last Jedi. First, we’ll give you their lists, and then we will let each editor have a chance to tear down the other editor’s list, so that we can come up with the true objective list of the eternally awesome best movies of all-time. Sound like fun? Here we go:
First up, let’s see Tim’s list:
And now let’s see if James can top Tim’s awesome list:
Let’s give the editors a chance to analyze each other’s list:
Tim:
I look at James’ list, and I have but one question for him:
Who hurt you?
While I have presented a flawless list of cinematic treasures, you are obviously showing off your comedy writing chops with that “list” of “best movies.” Forrest Gump? A mentally challenged Alabaman (but I repeat myself) does not make for a great story. It’s just three hours of Tom Hanks talking as slow as humanly possible while an invalid wheels around after him. Yeesh, buddy.
While I’ll admit that your list does contain a few good films, I won’t raise my children in a world where Zoolander is on a list of best films. Honestly, seeing that on your list raises some real concerns about your current mental state. We may need to call in a wellness check on you. I’m worried about you, buddy.
The presence of Last Crusade on a list that does not contain Raiders of the Lost Ark immediately raises red flags as well. Heresy, sir. Honestly, I hope you were drunk when you wrote this. It’s the best case scenario.
It is only through the common ground we find with The Fellowship of the Ring that we can remain cordial.
James now has a chance to respond...
James:
Look, I could make excuses for the ordering of my list. I can see with my own eyes that it represents the psyche of a wayward high school sophomore. It’s a haphazard set of selections clearly constructed by a man who was either a bit inebriated or who has some serious growing up to do.
But you know what? I’M STANDING BY MY LIST, darn it. I love every single one of those movies. I literally did my senior pictures in high school in the “Blue Steel” pose from Zoolander. I still cry every single time I watch Forrest Gump. And whenever I have the rare night at home without the kids, by golly I’m watching John Wick and Deadpool do all sorts of shenanigans while I laugh my butt off.
Look, I respect Tim and his well-thought-out list. I know you’re supposed to like Raiders of the Lost Ark more than Last Crusade. I’m a man of the people, okay? I’m the slack-jawed dummy who just wants to see flagpoles chucked into Nazi wheel spokes. Sure, The Shawshank Redemption is great, it powerfully portrays what a man can sustain without losing his soul, blah blah. But what about the depths that Zoolander explores when he loses Male Model of the Year to Hansel?? Listen to Derek Zoolander as he wrestles with the big questions of life:
Derek Zoolander: “Maybe we should be doing something meaningful with our lives. Like helping people.”
Fellow male model: “Uh, Derek? What people?”
Derek Zoolander: “I don’t know! People who need help!”
You just won’t find that kind of dialogue on Tim’s list. We’re not here for the cinematic excellence of The Godfather. We’re here for what movie catches you when the chips are down, and that’s Deadpool throwing on Dolly Parton’s “9 to 5” and cutting a bunch of guys’ limbs off.
Oh, glad we agree on Fellowship. Thank goodness we’ve got that.
Okay, now we ask you subscribers, who has the better list? — Oh wait, what’s that? We have a late last minute entry from the editor-in-chief, Kyle Mann.
The other editors have now given up defending their list and would like to make a joint announcement that they were wrong, idiotic, and foolish. Kyle’s list is objectively the ultimate list of best movies of all-time.
Let us know in the comments how Kyle’s list is objectively correct.